- Dale R. Broadhurst's  SPALDING  RESEARCH  PROJECT -

Solomon Spalding
(1761 - 1816)
Oberlin Spalding MS /Book of Mormon
Textual Comparisons Mark-up
(using 1885 RLDS edition)


Chapter XIV: pp. 135-137

   
  • pg. 135
  •    
  • pg. 136
  •    
  • pg. 137

  •    
  • color-code legend
  •    
  • special citations

  •    
  • NOTE: THIS PAGE IS UNDER CONSTRUCTION,
        CONTENTS ARE UNCHECKED & PRELIMINARY
        (LAST REVISED:  OCT. 13, 1998)



  • Spalding/BoM "Unique Textual Parallels"   |   Sample Color Mark-up from 1830 Book of Alma

     


    Oberlin Spalding MS / Book of Mormon
    Experimental Textual Comparison

    Color Code Legend and Comments




    brown text = words found in the Oberlin Ms & Book of Mormon

    brown CAPs = words relatively unique to the Oberlin Ms & B. of M.

    underlined = phraseology common to the Oberlin Ms & B. of M.
    (Only a few examples have been marked -- for more see special citations)


    green text = related words (sharing common root) in Oberlin Ms & B. of M.

    blue text = Proper nouns appearing only in the Oberlin Manuscript

    blue bold = Oberlin Ms. words not in the Book of Mormon



     

       


     
     

                               The  "Manuscript   Found."                          135

     
         
      defend the fort against such a formidable force. Lamoch 01
      however placed himself at the head of about one thousand  
      warriors and attempted to beat them back from the walls and  
      prevent their making a breach. But it was impossible with  
      his small band to withstand the strength of such a mighty 05
      army. They broke down part of the palisades and entered  
      the fort through the breach; and immediately began the massacre  
      of the defenseless multitude without regard to age or sex  
      Sambal, being anxious to find Lamesa, rushed forward with  
      a small band and surrounded a small block house. He then 10
      broke down the door and entered. Here he beheld all the  
      ladies of the imperial family and many other ladies of dis-  
      tinction. He instantly sprang towards Lamesa in order to  
      seize her but was prevented by Heliza, who stepped between  
      them and, falling upon her knees, implored him to spare the 15
      life of Lamesa. Scarce had she spoken when the cruel  
      MONSTER buried his sword in her bosom and she fell lifeless  
      before the eyes of her dearest friend. Lamesa gave a  
      scream, and looking fiercely on Sambal, she exclaimed. "Thou  
      MONSTER of villainy and cruelty, could nothing satiate your 20
      revenge but the death of my dear friend, the amiable,  
      the innocent Heliza? Here is my heart; I am prepared for your next  
      victim." "Ah. no." says Sambal, "Your life is safe from my  
      sword. I shall conduct you to my palace and you shall be  
      honored with me for your partner." "Insult me not," says 25
      she, "thou malicious , bloody villain. Either kill me or be  
      gone from my sight; my eyes can never endure the man  
      who is guilty of such monstrous crimes." "Set your heart at  
      rest," says he, "my dear Lamesa. I will convince you that I  
      am a better man than your beloved Elseon; his head shall 30
      soon satiate my revenge and then you shall be the Queen of  
      Sciota." At this instant a loud voice was heard: "The Ken- 32
         




     

       


     
     

    136                            The  "Manuscript   Found."                          

     
         
      tucks are marching with a prodigious army towards the fort!" 01
      Sambal, turning to his warriors present, ordered them to  
      guard the women in that house and not permit any of them  
      to escape. "For" says he, "I must go and destroy that army  
      of Kentucks." Great already had been the slaughter which 05
      the Sciotans had made of the citizens in the fort. Those  
      who had attempted to escape through a gate which was thrown  
      open were met and MASSACRED by the Sciotan warriors on the  
      outside. But their progress was arrested by the appearance of  
      Elseon at the head of thirty thousand warriors. They had 10
      marched with the greatest speed, for they were informed  
      by an express that the Sciotans had invested the fort.  
      When Sambal beheld them he instantly concluded to  
      draw his army out of the fort and to try a battle with them  
      in the open field. His orders were immediately spread 15
      through every part of the fort where his men were employed  
      in killing the defenseless and in fighting Lamoch and the little band  
      of desperate heroes whom [he] commanded. The  
      Sciotans were soon formed and marched out of the fort and  
      paraded in proper order for battle. Elseon, observing this, 20
      commanded his men to halt and made his arrangements  
      to rush forward and commence the attack. Having brand-  
      ished his sword as a token for silence, he then spoke. 23
         
           "My brave warriors. The glorious period has arrived 24
      to display our valor in the destruction of our 25
      enemies. What monstrous cruelties have they perpetrated.  
      Behold your city in ruins; listen to the cries of your mur-  
      dered friends whose innocent blood calls for vengeance;  
      consider the situation of those who are surrounded by the  
      walls of yonder fort. How many thousands are MASSACRED 30
      and how many must share their fate unless you fight like he-  
      roes? By our valor we can effect their deliverance and rid 32
         




     

       


     
     

                               The  "Manuscript   Found."                          137

     
         
      our country from the most FEROCIOUS   band of murderers that ever dis- 01
      graced humanity. Their standard is that of the Sciotan  
      King, whose malice and vengeful disposition have produced  
      this horrid war. Urged on by his malignant passions he has  
      engaged [and] undertaken a most dangerous and mad enterprise. 05
      He has thrown himself and his army into a most critical and  
      dangerous situation.  
      Fight as you did at the great Battle of Geheno and your ene-  
      mies will be prostrate in the dust; and your names shall be  
      illustrious. Rush forward my brave warriors and let your 10
      motto   be 'victory or death.'" 11
         
           Not a moment, when his warriors were stimulated for 12
      the combat, did Elseon tarry, but marched with precipitation,  
      prepared to make a most furious chargeSambal was  
      ready to meet him, and marched forward with equal boldness 15
      and celerity. The charge was tremendous. Not the dashing  
      against each other of two mighty ships in a hurricane upon  
      the boisterous ocean could have been more terrible. Each  
      warrior, fearless of danger, met his antagonist, determined to  
      destroy his life or lose his own in the contest. The battle 20
      extended through every part of both armies. As warriors fell  
      in the front ranks, their places were supplied from the rear,  
      and reserved bands rushing between the divisions were met  
      by others of equal strength and valorHelicon, the intimate  
      friend of Elseon, beheld Sambal, who was encouraging his 25
      warriors to fight bravely, as no other alternative re-  
      mained for them but victory or death. When Helicon be-  
      held him his youthful mind felt the impulse of ambition;  
      he sprang towards Sambal and challenged him to the com-  
      bat. Sambal gave him no time to repeat the challenge, but 30
      rushed upon him with more fury than a tiger, and with his 31
         



     

    Special Citations of Textual Parallelisms in pp. 135-37


    (RLDS 135:01-a) [ the Kentucks were unprepared ] to defend the fort . . .
    [ObMs xxx]

    (RLDS 135:01-b) . . . I do take my sword to defend the cause of my country . . .
    [Alma 60:28 LDS]



    (RLDS 135:01-c) [ the Kentucks were unprepared to ] defend the fort . . .
    [ObMs xxx]

    (RLDS 135:01-d) And thus were the Nephites prepared to . . . climb up
    to enter the fort by any other way . . .
    [Alma 49:19 LDS]



    (RLDS 135:01-e) to defend the fort against such a formidable force . . .
    [ObMs xxx]

    (RLDS 135:01-f) . . . those priests that . . . had caused such a great destruction
    to come upon them.
    [Mosiah 21:20 LDS]

    (RLDS 135:01-g) . . . having been such a highly favored people of the Lord . . .
    [Alma 9:20 LDS]

    (RLDS 135:01-h) . . . we know not such a being; neither do ye; but if it so be
    that there is such a thing . . .
    [Alma 54:21 LDS]

    (RLDS 135:01-i) . . . ye have hinted that he hath gone to such a place?
    [Alma 54:22 LDS]

    (RLDS 135:01-j) That it is not reasonable that such a being as a Christ shall come; if so, and he be the Son of God . . .
    [Helaman 16:18 LDS]



    (RLDS 135:02-a) Lamoch however placed himself at the head of about . . .
    [ObMs xxx]

    (RLDS 135:02-b) Amalickiah's intention . . . place himself at their head
    and dethrone the king . . .
    [Alma 47:08 LDS]

    (RLDS 135:02-c) . . . the brother of Shared . . . came . . . and placed himself
    upon the throne of Coriantumr.
    [Ether 14:05-06 LDS]



    (RLDS 135:02-d) Lamoch . . . himself at the head of about one thousand
    warriors . . .
    [ObMs xxx]

    (RLDS 135:02-e) Helaman did march at the head of his two thousand
    stripling soldiers
    [Alma 53:22 LDS]

    (RLDS 135:02-f) Helaman, did march at the head of these two thousand
    young men . . .
    Alma 56:09 LDS]



    (RLDS 135:02-g) at the head of about one thousand warriors . . .
    [ObMs xxx]

    (RLDS 135:02-h) . . . peace did remain for the space of about four years . . .
    [Mormon 1:12 LDS]



    (RLDS 135:02-i) at the head of about one thousand warriors . . .
    [ObMs xxx]

    (RLDS 135:02-j) . . . there were about three thousand five hundred souls . . .
    [Alma 4:05 LDS]

    (RLDS 135:02-k) . . . they were in number about four thousand who had not been slain.
    [Alma 62:17 LDS]

    (RLDS 135:02-l) . . . they were in number about two thousand and five . . .
    [3 Nephi 17:25 LDS]



    (RLDS 135:02-m) at the head of about one thousand warriors . . .
    [ObMs xxx]

    (RLDS 135:02-n) . . . for they were great warriors;
    [Alma 51:31 LDS]



    (RLDS 135:03-a) placed himself . . . and attempted to beat them back . . .
    [ObMs xxx]

    (RLDS 135:03-b) And they stood forth and attempted to lay their hands . . .
    [Mosiah 13:02 LDS]



    (RLDS 135:03-c) Lamoch . . . attempted to beat them back from the walls . . .
    [ObMs xxx]

    (RLDS 135:03-d) . . . the Lamanites did beat them, and drove them back,
    and slew many of them.
    [Mosiah 21:08 LDS]

    (RLDS 135:03-e) . . . Nephites did beat them . . . they did fall back from
    before them.
    [3 Nephi 4:12 LDS]

    (RLDS 135:03-f) the Nephites did beat the Lamanites . . . many of them.
    [Mormon 1:11 LDS]

    (RLDS 135:03-g) . . . we did pursue them . . . and did beat them . . .
    [Mormon 2:26 LDS]

    (RLDS 135:03-h) . . . in that year we did beat them . . . did beat them again . . .
    [Mormon 3:07-08 LDS]

    (RLDS 135:03-i) . . . the Lamanites did not beat them until they had come
    again the second time.
    [Mormon 4:20 LDS]

    (RLDS 135:03-j) And Cohor, the son of Noah, caused that his people
    should give battle unto Shule, in which Shule did beat them . . .
    [Ether 7:21 LDS]

    (RLDS 135:03-k) . . . press upon the armies of Shiz that they beat them . . .
    [Ether 15:10 LDS]



    (RLDS 135:03-l) Lamoch . . . attempted to beat them back from the walls . . .
    [ObMs xxx]

    (RLDS 135:03-m) . . . he did cast himself down from the wall, and did flee . . .
    [Helaman 16:07 LDS]



    (RLDS 135:04-a) prevent their making a breach.
    [ObMs xxx]

    (RLDS 135:04-b) . . . because of their . . . making a mock of that which was sacred,
    [Helaman 4:12 LDS]



    (RLDS 135:04-c) prevent their making a breach.
    [ObMs xxx]

    (RLDS 135:04-d) . . . let us make a breach therein for us . . .
    [2 Nephi 17:06 LDS - quoting Isaiah]



    (RLDS 135:04-e) But it was impossible . . . to withstand the strength of such
    a mighty army.
    [ObMs xxx]

    (RLDS 135:04-f) . . . the Lamanites being so numerous, it was impossible
    for the people of Limhi to contend with them,
    [Mosiah 22:02 LDS]

    (RLDS 135:04-g) Teancum made preparations . . . but . . . it was impossible . . .
    [Alma 52:17 LDS]

    (RLDS 135:04-h) . . . so numerous . . . it became impossible for the Nephites
    to obtain more power over them
    [Helaman 4:19 LDS]



    (RLDS 135:04-i) impossible with his small band to withstand . . .
    [ObMs xxx]

    (RLDS 135:04-j) Now there began to be a war upon all the face of the land, every man with his band fighting for that which he desired.
    [Ether 13:25 LDS]

    (RLDS 135:04-k) . . . we could lead them out of the city by our small bands.
    [Alma 58:01 LDS]



    (RLDS 135:04-l) it was impossible . . . to withstand the strength of such . . .
    [ObMs xxx]

    (RLDS 135:04-m) therefore he was not able to withstand his blows . . .
    [Alma 1:09 LDS]



    (RLDS 135:05-a) withstand the strength of such a mighty army.
    [ObMs xxx]

    (RLDS 135:05-b) . . . such . . . strength; and with such mighty power . . .
    [Alma 56:56]



    (RLDS 135:05-c) the strength of such a mighty army.
    [ObMs xxx]

    (RLDS 135:05-d) . . . discover the number and the strength of our army.
    [Alma 58:14 LDS]



    (RLDS 135:06-a) They broke down part of the palisades and entered the fort . . .
    [ObMs xxx]

    (RLDS 135:06-b) . . . they broke the cords with which they were bound . . .
    [Alma 14:26 LDS]

    (RLDS 135:06-c) . . . the sons . . . broke down the door of the prison and
    brought out their father . . .
    [Ether 7:18 LDS]



    (RLDS 135:06-d) They broke down part of the palisades and entered the fort . . .
    [ObMs xxx]

    (RLDS 135:06-e) . . . were made pure and entered into the rest . . .
    [Alma 13:12 LDS]



    (RLDS 135:06-f) They . . . entered the fort through the breach;
    [ObMs xxx]

    (RLDS 135:06-g) . . . he entered the city Nephi with his armies . . .
    [Alma 47:31]

    (RLDS 135:06-h) . . . the Nephites . . . enter the fort by any other way . . .
    [Alma 49:19 LDS]



    (RLDS 135:06-i) and entered the fort through the breach;
    [ObMs xxx]

    (RLDS 135:06-j) . . . and we will pass through the secret pass on the left of
    their camp . . .
    {Mosiah 22:07 LDS]



    (RLDS 135:07-a) They . . . entered . . . and immediately began the massacre
    of the . . .
    [ObMs xxx]

    (RLDS 135:07-b) And . . . the Nephites began the foundation of a city . . .
    [Alma 19:31 LDS]

    (RLDS 135:07-c) And he, immediately . . . began to rebuke them . . .
    [Alma 50:13 LDS]

    (RLDS 135:07-d) . . . they came forth . . . and immediately returned to the . . .
    [Helaman 5:17 LDS]



    (RLDS 135:07-e) They . . . began the massacre of the . . .
    [ObMs xxx]

    (RLDS 135:07-f) . . . they should easily . . . slay and massacre them . . .
    [Alma 49:07 LDS]



    (RLDS 135:07-g) They . . . began the massacre the of the multitude . . .
    [ObMs xxx]

    (RLDS 135:07-h) . . . they could . . . because of the greatness of the multitude;
    [Mosiah 2:08 LDS]



    (RLDS 135:08-a) Sambal, being anxious to find Lamesa . . .
    [ObMs xxx]

    (RLDS 135:08-b) . . . I should go to find ore, that I might make tools.
    [1 Nephi 17:10 LDS]



    (RLDS 135:08-c) Sambal . . . rushed forward with a small band . . .
    [ObMs xxx]

    (RLDS 135:08-d) . . . Zerahemnah . . . rushed forward that he might slay
    Moroni . . .
    [Alma 44:12 LDS]

    (RLDS 135:08-e) . . . Amalickiah fled with a small number of his men . . .
    [Alma 46:33 LDS]

    (RLDS 135:08-f) . . . we could lead them out of the city by our small bands.
    [Alma 58:01 LDS]

    (RLDS 135:08-g) . . . Gid, with a small number of men . . . in the wilderness . . . and . . . Teomner and a small number of men . . .
    [Alma 58:16 LDS]

    (RLDS 135:08-h) Now there began to be a war upon all the face of the land, every man with his band fighting for that which he desired.
    [Ether 13:25 LDS]



    (RLDS 135:08-i) Sambal . . . rushed forward with a small band
    and surrounded a small block-house
    [ObMs xxx]

    (RLDS 135:08-j) . . . Lehonti came down with his men
    and surrounded the men of Amalickiah . . .
    [Alma 47:14 LDS]

    (RLDS 135:08-k) [Moroni] . . . caused the men . . . to withdraw . . .
    and surround the armies . . .
    [Alma 55:21 LDS]

    (RLDS 135:08-l) . . . Moroni . . . slew many, and surrounded many others . . .
    [Alma 62:25 LDS]



    (RLDS 135:09-a) He then broke down the door and entered.
    [ObMs xxx]

    (RLDS 135:09-b) . . . the sons . . . broke down the door . . . and brought . . .
    [Ether 7:18 LDS]

    (RLDS 135:09-c) . . . were made pure and entered into the rest . . .
    [Alma 13:12 LDS]



    (RLDS 135:09-d) Here he beheld all the ladies of the imperial family . . .
    [ObMs xxx]

    (RLDS 135:09-e) . . . and here he did not have much success . . .
    [Alma 30:21 LDS]

    (RLDS 135:09-f) . . . when Nephi arose he beheld the multitudes of people . . .
    [Helaman 7:12 LDS]



    Under Construction: more text to be added.




    return to top of page



    Spalding Studies Home  |    Spalding Studies Research  |    Spalding Research Project


    Last Revised: 4-22-2001