[ 3 ]
THE
"MANUSCRIPT FOUND."
A Verbatim Copy from the Original.
HEREWITH we present to the reader the notorious "Manuscript
Story" {"Manuscript Found}, of the later Rev. Solomon
Spalding. What gives this document prominence is
the fact that, for the past fifty years it has been made to do
duty by the opposers of the Book of Mormon and the
Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints, as the source,
the root, and the inspiration, by and from which Joseph
Smith and Sydney Rigdon wrote said Book of Mormon
and organized the Church. It has been popularly and
persistently claimed that the plan, subject matter, including
prominent names and localities, history of the origin of the
aboriginal races of America, with their arts and sciences,
civilizations and customs, were identical in this "Manuscript
Found" and in the Book of Mormon. Thousands have
believed this false and foolish statement, without giving its
truth or falsity an hour's fair and unprejudiced investigation,
and then fought the book and the church with a readiness
and a zeal almost without a parallel. And now that this
veritable "Manuscript Found," with an unbroken chain of
evidence proving its identity and running back to E. D.
Howe, D. P. Hurlbut, Spalding's "old trunk," and so back
4
The "Manuscript
Found."
to Pittsburgh, Conneaut, and to the very pen of Solomon
Spalding, has by the providence of God been furnished us,
and that, too, by those not of the Church, we take pleasure
in exhibiting in the sunlight of solid facts, this hob-goblin
of the pulpit, this "nigger-in-the-woodpile" of the press and
the forum, that with which they have fooled and frightened
the masses and blinded those inquiring into the origin and
character of the Book of Mormon.
This seeming huge hindrance and insurmountable obstacle
which is always thrown in the way of the investigator
with all the skill and power that craft and cunning
and malice and fear and blind zeal can invent and command,
vanishes from the presence of this original witness
in the case; for when it speaks it reveals the flimsiness and
falsity of the claim that it was in any way or in any sense
the origin of the Book of Mormon, or that there is the least
likeness between the two. This newly found "missing link"
completes the chain of evidence which proves that the
"Manuscript Found" never was and never could be made
the occasion, cause, or germ of the Book of Mormon.
Mr. Spalding has been exalted by the opposers of the
Latter Day Saints to the very pinnacle of fame, as a very
learned, very moral, and very pious man. It is fortunate
that his true measure and worth in respect to his learning,
his morals, and his piety, is now furnished us in this "Manuscript
Story." God judges men by their words, and it is
wise for men to judge of each other after this manner. And
when we estimate Mr. Spalding by the character of his
work as exhibited in this document, we must grade him
down to a very low level, whether in respect to scholarship.
mental power, moral purity, or pious attainments and tendencies.
The "Manuscript Found."
5
==> The following Correspondence explains the manner
in which the Manuscript was preserved and placed
in the hands of the present publishers.
This from the Bibliotheca Sacra was republished in
many leading journals east and west, among them the
Herald of Grinnell, Iowa; the Western Watchman,
Eureka, California; the New York Observer, and Frank
Leslie's Sunday Magazine.
"The theory of the origin of the Book of Mormon in
the traditional manuscript of Solomon Spaulding will
probably have to be relinquished. That manuscript is
doubtless now in the possession of Mr. L.L. Rice, of
Honolulu, Hawaiian Islands, formerly an anti-slavery
editor in Ohio, and for many years State printer at
Columbus, During a recent visit to Honolulu, I
suggested to Mr. Rice that he might have valuable
anti-slavery documents in his possession which he
would be willing to contribute to the rich
collection already in the Oberlin College Library.
In pursuance of this suggestion Mr. Rice began
looking over his old pamphlets and papers, and at
length came upon an old, worn, and faded manuscript
of about 175 pages, small quarto, purporting to be a
history of the migrations and conflicts of the
ancient Indian tribes which occupied the territory
now belonging to the states of New York, Ohio and
Kentucky. On the last page of this manuscript is a
certificate and signature giving the names of
several persons known to the signer, who have
assured him that, to their personal knowledge, the
manuscript was the writing of Solomon Spaulding. Mr.
Rice has no recollection how or when this manuscript
came into his possession. It was enveloped in a
coarse piece of wrapping paper and endorsed in Mr.
Rice's handwriting "A Manuscript Story."
There seems no reason to doubt that this is the
long-lost story. Mr. Rice, myself, and others
compared it with the Book of Mormon, and could
detect no resemblance between the two, in general or
in detail. There seems to be no name or incident
common to the two. The solemn style of the Book of
Mormon, in imitation of the English
6
The "Manuscript
Found."
Scriptures, does not appear in the manuscript. The only resemblance
is in the fact that both profess to set forth the history of lost
tribes. Some other explanation of the origin of the Book of Mormon
must be found, if any explanation is required. Signed, James
H. Fairchild
The letter below was written in answer to our suggestion
that the Manuscript be sent for safe keeping to
some Historical Society in Chicago, Illinois.
HONOLULU, Sandwich Islands,
March 28th, 1885.
MR. JOSEPH SMITH:
The Spaulding Manuscript in my possession came into
my hands in this wise. In 1839-40 my partner and myself bought
of E. D. Howe the Painseville Telegraph, published at Painesville,
Ohio. The transfer of the printing department, types, press, &c.,
was accompanied with a large collection of books, manuscripts, &c.,
this manuscript of Spaulding's among the rest. So, you see, it has
been in my possession over forty years. But I never examined it, or
knew the character of it, until some six or eight months since. The
wrapper was marked, "Manuscript Story -- Conneaut Creek." The
wonder is, that in some of my movements, I did not destroy or burn
it with a large amount of rubbish that had accumulated from time
to time.
It happened that Pres't Fairchild was here on a visit, at the time
I discovered the contents of it, and it was examined by him and
others with much curiosity. Since Pres't Fairchild published the
fact of its existence in my possession, I have had applications for it
from half a dozen sources, each applicant seeming to think that he
or she was entitled to it. Mr. Howe says when he was getting up a
book to expose Mormonism as a fraud at an early day, when the
Mormons had their head-quarters at Kirtland, he obtained it from
spme source, and it was inadvertently transferred with the other
effects of his printing office. A. B. Deming, of Painesville, who is
also getting up some kind of a book I believe on Mormonism, wants
me to send it to him. Mrs. Dickinson, of Boston, claiming to be a
relative of Spaulding, and who is getting up a book to show that he
The "Manuscript Found."
7
was the real author of the Book of Mormon, wants it. She thinks,
at least, it should be sent to Spaulding's daughter, a Mrs. Somebody
-- but she does not inform me where she lives. Deming says that
Howe borrowed it when he was getting up his book, and did not return
it, as he should have done, &c.
This Manuscript does not purport to be "a story of the Indians
formerly occupying this continent;" but is a history of the wars between
the Indians of Ohio and Kentucky, and their progress in civilization,
&c. It is certain that this Manuscript is not the origin of
the Mormon Bible, whatever some other manuscripts may have been.
The only similarity between them, is, in the manner in which each
purports to have been found -- one in a cave on Conneaut Creek --
the other in a hill in Ontario county, New York. There is no identity
of names, of persons, or places; and there is no similarity of style
between them. As I told Mr. Deming, I should as soon think
the Book of Revelations was written by the author of Don Quixotte,
as that the writer of this Manuscript was the author of the Book of
Mormon. Deming says Spaulding made three copies of "Manuscript
Found," one of which Sidney Rigdon stole from a printing
office in Pittsburg. You can possibly tell better than I can, what
ground there is for such an allegation.
As to this Manuscript, I can not see that it can be of any use to
any body, except the Mormons, to show that it is not the original of
the Mormon Bible. But that would not settle the claim that some
other manuscript of Spaulding was the original of it. I propose to
hold it in my own hands for a while, to see if it can not be put to
some good use. Deming and Howe inform me that its existence is
exciting great interest in that region. I am underf a tacit, but not
a positive pledge to President Fairchild, to deposit it eventually in
the Library of Oberlin College. I shall be free from that pledge,
when I see an opportunity to put it to a better use.
Yours, &c.,
L. L. RICE.
P. S. -- Upon reflection, since writing the foregoing, I am of the
opinion that no one who reads this Manuscript will give credit to the
story that Solomon Spaulding was in any wise the author of the
Book of Mormon. It is unlikely that any one who wrote so elaborate
a work as the Mormon Bible, would spend his time in getting
8
The "Manuscript
Found."
up so shallow a story as this, which at best is but a feeble imitation
of the other. Finally I am more than half convinced that this is his
only writing of the sort, and that any pretence that Spaulding was in
any sense the author of the other, is a sheer fabrication. It was easy
for any body who may have seen this, or heard anything of its contents.
to get up the story that they were identical.
L. L. R.
HONOLULU, Sandwich Islands,
May 14th, 1885.
MR. JOSEPH SMITH; Dear Sir: --
I am greatly obliged to you for the information concerning
Mormonism, in your letters of April 30th and May 2d. As I am
in no sense a Mormonite, of course it is a matter of curiosity, mainly,
that I am interested in the history of Mormonism.
Two things are true concerning this manuscript in my possession:
First, it is a genuine writing of Solomon Spaulding; and second.
it is not the original of the Book of Mormon.
My opinion is, from all I have seen and learned, that this is the
only writing of Spaulding, and there is no foundation for the statement
of Deming and others, that Spaulding made another story,
more elaborate, of which several copies were written, one of which
Rigdon stole from a printing office in Pittsburgh, &c. Of course I
can not be as certain of this, as of the other two points. One theory
is, that Rigdon, or some one else, saw this manuscript, or heard it
read, and from the hints it conveyed, got up the other and more
elaborate writing on which the Book of Mormon was founded.
Take that for what it is worth. It don't seem to me very likely.
You may be at rest as to my putting the manuscript into the
possession of any one who will mutilate it, or use it for a bad purpose.
I shall have it deposited in the Library of Oberlin College,
in Ohio, to be at the disposal for reading of any one who may wish
to peruse it; but not to be removed from that depository. My
friend, President Fairchild, may be relied on as security for the safe
keeping of it. It will be sent there in July, by a friend who is going
there to "take to himself a wife." Meantime, I have made a literal
copy of the entire document -- errors of orthography, grammar,
The "Manuscript Found."
9
erasures, and all -- which I shall keep in my possession, so that any
attempt to mutilate it will be of easy detection and exposure. Oberlin
is a central place, in the vicinity of Conneaut, where the manuscript
was written.
I have had an idea, sometimes, that it is due to the Mormons to
have a copy of it, if they took interest in it enough to publish it.
As it is only of interest as showing that it is not the original of the
Book of Mormon, no one else is likely to wish it for publication.
Miss Dickinson, whom you call a granddaughter of Solomon
Spaulding, represents herself to me as his grandniece: "My great
uncle, Rev. Solomon Spaulding," she writes.
Rev. Dr. Hyde, President of the Institution, in this place, for
training Native Missionaries for Micronesia, (a very prominent and
successful institution), has written an elaborate account of this
manuscript, and of Mormonism, and sent it for publication in the
Congregationalist, of Boston. I presume it will be published, and
you will be interested in reading it.
Very respectfully, yours,
L. L. RICE.
In a postscript Mr. Rice says he found the following
endorsement on the Manuscript:
"The writings of Solomon Spaulding proved by Aron Wright,
Oliver Smith, John N. Miller and others. The testimonies of the
above gentlemen are now in my possession.
(Signed)
D. P. HURLBUT."
COPY OF MR. RICE'S LETTER
HONOLULU, H. I., June 12, 1885.
PRESIDENT J. H. FAIRCHILD: --
Herewith I send to you the Solomon Spalding Manuscript,
to be deposited in the Library of Oberlin College, for reference
by any one who may be desirous of seeing or examining it. As a
great deal of inquiry has been made about it since it became known
that it was in my possession, I deem it proper that it be deposited for
10
The "Manuscript
Found."
safe keeping, where any one interested in it, whether Mormon or
Anti-Mormon, may examine it. It has been in my possession forty-six
years -- from 1839 to 1885 -- and for forty-four years of that time
no one examined it, and I was not aware of the character of its contents.
I send it to you enclosed in the same wrapper, and tied
with the same string that must have enclosed it for near half a century
-- certainly during the forty-six years since it came into my possession.
I have made and retain in my possession a correct literal
copy of it, errors of orthography, of grammar, erasures and all. I
may allow the Mormons of Utah to print from this copy,
which they are anxious to do; and a delegation is now in the Islands,
awaiting my decision on this point. They claim that they are entitled
to whatever benefit they may derive from its publication; and
it seems to me there is some justice in that claim. Whether it will
relieve them in any measure, from the imputation that Solomon
Spalding was the author of the Book of Mormon, I do not attempt
to decide. It devolves upon their opponents to show that there are
or were other writings of Spalding -- since it is evident that this writing
is not the original of the Mormon Bible.
Truly, yours, &c.,
L. L. RICE.
P. S. -- The words "Solomon Spaulding's Writings" in ink on
the wrapper were written by me, after I became aware of the contents.
The words "Manuscript Story -- Conneaut Creek," in faint
penciling, were as now when it came into my possession.
L. L. R.
OBERLIN COLLEGE, OBERLIN, O.,
July 23, 1885.
I have this day delivered to Mr. E. L. Kelley a copy of the Manuscript
of Solomon Spaulding, sent from Honolulu by Mr. L. L.
Rice, to the Library of Oberlin College, for safe keeping, and now in
my care. The copy was prepared at Mr. Kelley's request, under my
supervision, and is, as I believe, an exact transcript of the original
manuscript, including erasures, misspellings, &c.
JAS. H. FAIRCHILD,
Prest. of Oberlin College.
The "Manuscript Found."
11
KIRTLAND, O., 24th July, 1885.
PRES. W. W. BLAIR, Lamoni, Iowa:
Herewith I transmit to you the copy of the Spaulding
Manuscript prepared by Pes. Fairchild, as attested by him, together
with his certificate, and photograph sheets.
E. L. KELLEY.
Words and sentences underlined were stricken out in the Manuscript.
Placeds marked thus - - - - the copy was illegible.
INTRODUCTION,
Near the west bank of the Coneaught River there are
the remains of an ancient fort. As I was walking and forming
various conjectures respecting the character, situation, &
numbers of those people who far exceeded the present Indians
in works of art and ingenuity, I hapned to tread on a
flat stone. This was at a small distance from the fort, &
it lay on the top of a small mound of Earth exactly
horizontal. The face of it had a singular appearance. I
discovered a number of characters which appeared to me to
be letters, but so much effaced by the ravages of time, that
I could not read the inscription. With the assistance of a
leaver I raised the stone. But you may easily conjecture
my astonishment when I discovered that its ends and sides
rested on stones & that it was designed as a cover to an artificial
Cave. I found by examining that its sides were lined
with stones built in a connical form with - - - - - down, &
that it was about eight feet deep. Determined to investigate
the design of this extraordinary work of antiquity, I
12
The "Manuscript
Found."
prepared myself with necessary requisites for that purpose
and decended to the Bottom of the Cave. Observing
one side to be perpendicular nearly three feet from the bottom,
I began to inspect that part with accuracy. Here I
noticed a big flat stone fixed in the form of a doar. I immediately
tore it down and Lo, a cavity within the wall
presented itself it being about three feet in diamiter from
side to side and about two feet high. Within this cavity I
found an earthen Box with a cover which shut it perfectly
tite. The Box was two feet in length one & half in breadth
& one & three inches in diameter. My mind filled with
awful sensations which crowded fast upon me would hardly
permit my hands to remove this venerable deposit, but curiosity
soon gained the assendancy & the box was taken &
raised to open it. When I had removed the Cover I found
that it contained twenty-eight rolls of parchment -- & -- that
when - - - appeared to be manuscrips written in eligant
hand with Roman letters & in the Latin Language.
They were written on a variety of Subjects. But the
Roll which principally attracted my attention contained a
history of the author's life & that part of America which
extends along the great Lakes & the waters of the Mississippy.
Extracts of the most interesting and important matters
contained in this Roll I take the liberty to publish.
Gentle Reader, tread lightly on the ashes of the venerable
dead. Thou must know that this Country was once
inhabited by great and powerful nations, considerably civilized
& skilled in the arts of war, & that on ground where
thou now treadest many a bloody Battle hath been fought,
& heroes by thousands have been made to bite the dust.
The "Manuscript Found."
13
In the history given of these nations by my author you
will find nothing but what will correspond with the natural
sentiments we should form on viewing the innumerable remains
of antiquity which are scattered over an extensive
Country. This is an evidence of the author's impartiality
and veracity. But if any should pretend that the whole
story is fictitious or fabulous
To publish a translation of every particular circumstance
mentioned by our author would produce a volume
too expensive for the general class of readers. But should
this attempt to throw off the veil which has secluded our
view from the transactions o nations who for ages have been
extinct, meet the approbation of the public, I shall then be
happy to gratify the more inquisitive and learned part of
my readers by a more minute publication. Apprehensive
that skeptical illiberal or superstitious minds may censure
this performance with great acrimony I have only to remark
that they will be deprived of a great fund of entertainment
- - - - of a contrary disposition will obtain. My
compassion will be excited more than my resentment and
there the contest will end.
Now, Gentle Reader, the Translator who wishes well to
thy present and thy future existence entreats thee to peruse
this volume with a clear head, a pure heart, and a candid
mind. If thou shalt then find that thy head and thy heart
are both improved it will afford him more satisfaction than
the approbation of ten thousand who have received no
benefit.
And now permit me to admonish thee, that if thou
shouldst reside in or travel through any part of the Country
|